It's all very well and good when my students are chatty and open, but sometimes maybe I want them to be a bit more reserved. Tonight I presented a worksheet to my high school class consisting of two boys and a girl, all in the second grade of high school, which works out to about grade 11 in Canadian terms. The worksheet presented the rather unlikely scenario of being on a sinking ship in
eel shark infested waters, with a lifeboat that only seats seven (of which you have apparently taken control, presumably with a large gun of some sort), but enough time to stop and think about who you want on the boat with you as you make the 10 km journey to a small desert island.
The theory was that they would debate the good and bad points of each potential lifeboat survivor and then come to a consensus on who the lucky six were. (So, actually, this lifeboat seems to seat nine, with the three English-studying teenagers ruling it with iron fists.) All three easily agreed on saving the farmer and the housewife (because she "could cook the food" and "help everyone else" and oh, the tongue-biting I did). The 40 year old male nurse vs the 60 year old female doctor was more of a heated debate, although they did all agree that at least one medical professional had to make it on. Just to stir things up a bit, I pointed out that it didn't specify what kind of doctor she is. Personally, I'd probably rather take my luck with the nurse than a neurosurgeon, but in the end they managed to agree to save both. So that was four.
The religious leader was tossed almost immediately, as was the wrestler. I eventually had to force them to choose between the male comedian and the female actress, and while my female student was not convinced we needed either of them, one boy felt very strongly that saving the 25 year old actress was of paramount importance. For, y'know, spirit lifting purposes. Of course.
The 17 year old unmarried pregnant girl turned out to be quite contentious. The first thing the actress-saving boy asked when he read her description was "Is she pretty?", although in the end, he and the female student wanted to save her because of the baby. The other boy, though, was having none of that. With the exception of the homemaker and the elderly doctor, he wanted a lifeboat filled with young(ish) strong males, on the grounds that they'd survive longer and would be more useful around the desert island. The pregnant teen, he argued, would require too much care and would not be very useful. "Besides," he said, "think about it. She's 17 and pregnant. She is not a good girl."
So getting pregnant at a young age is now grounds for being fed to sharks? Okay then...
Oh, but it gets worse. The other boy lit up at this, smacked his friend on the arm, and said "Yes. Exactly.
She's not a good girl." At which point the female student literally sprang from her chair in disgust and I wondered if I'd be able to bleach my brain out later.
In the end, though, I forced the horny teenager to choose between the actress and the teenager and he opted for the actress.
In the end it was a fun and lively exercise, but it gave me far too much insight into the minds of sixteen year old boys for comfort.